WAS IT THE RIGHT CALL?!

by WingNutWendy· 18 replies· started 2mo ago
Share𝕏Reddit
WW

i dont know man we gave away our future for a pick 😕 but its hard to argue with getting that kinda talent at #23 NOW LETS SEE HIM PLAY SOMETIME!!!

RR

I think we're giving Sebastian Cossa short shrift here, Wendy. He won the Calder Cup and earned that trade value, maybe it was a fair price to pay for the pick.

HH

IT WASNT THE CALDER CUP THAT EARNED US THAT PICK SEBASTIAN COSSA IS TALENT BUT HE AINT NICK FOLIGNO 😂 @RedWingRusty

W4

@HockeytownHank come on Hank, don't be like that! Sebastian Cossa earned his trade value after leading GR to the Calder Cup, we had to give up something for that #23 pick and he's still a valuable asset for us in the future. LGRW!

RD

@HockeytownHank don't be so quick to dismiss Sebastian Cossa's value just yet! He won a Calder Cup and that's no small feat, maybe his trade value isn't as low as you think.

HH
@HockeytownHank don't be so quick to dismiss Sebastian Cossa's value just yet! He won a Calder Cup and that's no small feat, maybe his trade value isn't as…

CALDER CUP CHAMPIONS ARE A BUNCH, RANDY - it don't matter where he won it!

K8
KaneFan882mo ago

come on hank calm down

HH
come on hank calm down

HA! NOT CALM DOWN WHEN IT COMES TO THE TRUTH, KANE'S FAN - Cossa's a fine goalie but he ain't Nick Foligno and we got better than that for the #23 pick!

WW

@KaneFan88 SHUT UP KANE'S FAN WE DONT NEED YOUR OPINION HERE!!! Hank's got a point about Cossa's value though 🙄

DG
doug_g2mo ago
come on hank calm down

Come on Kane's fan, Wendy's got a point about Hank's take - at least he's not sugarcoating things like most of us are, 10 years and counting after all...

HH
@doug_g said:
Come on Kane's fan, Wendy's got a point about Hank's take - at least he's not sugarcoating things like most of us are, 10 years and counting after all...

10 YEARS AND COUNTING, YOU SAID IT doug_g!!! That's why we can't just sugarcoat things around here WE EXPECT ANSWERS FROM OUR PLAYERS & COACHES!

BW
DetroitTom2mo ago
10 YEARS AND COUNTING, YOU SAID IT doug_g!!! That's why we can't just sugarcoat things around here WE EXPECT ANSWERS FROM OUR PLAYERS & COACHES!

I'm calling Hank's take a bit harsh, we got decent value for Cossa and a pick that could be a real asset down the line - it's not all or nothing. Don't know about you, but I'm more interested in seeing how our young D corps develops this year @HockeytownHank.

RR

@DetroitTom I agree that Hank's take was harsh, but let's also acknowledge that DetroitTom, we didn't get an A+ return for Cossa and his value was at least part of the reason Kane was so interested in staying. Not saying it's a bad deal overall, just tempering expectations with some realism.

MM
@DetroitTom I agree that Hank's take was harsh, but let's also acknowledge that DetroitTom, we didn't get an A+ return for Cossa and his value was at least…

@HockeytownHank is right though, it's been a decade since we've held anyone accountable - time for that to change!!! and can we stop saying "value" in relation to Cossa like he's some kind of trade chip 🙄

WW
@HockeytownHank is right though, it's been a decade since we've held anyone accountable - time for that to change!!! and can we stop saying "value" in…

@MotorCityMolly PREACHING TO THE CHURCH HERE!!! Finally someone with some guts to say whats been plaguin us for yrs! 👍

BW
DetroitTom2mo ago
@MotorCityMolly PREACHING TO THE CHURCH HERE!!! Finally someone with some guts to say whats been plaguin us for yrs! 👍

@WingNutWendy I think Molly's point about accountability needs more context - where do we draw the line and who gets held accountable? Maybe we should be asking questions like "how effective have our player development programs been?" before pointing fingers @HockeytownHank, still think it's too early to judge this rebuild.

HH
@WingNutWendy I think Molly's point about accountability needs more context - where do we draw the line and who gets held accountable? Maybe we should be…

DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN A JOKE FOR TOO LONG! WE GET IT, MOLLY AND WENDY, YOU WANT ACCOUNTABILITY NOW LET'S SEE SOME ACTION!!!

GG

ngl @HockeytownHank's just mad cuz we had a good development year, imo Calder Cup win was biggest positive of our offseason so far

AA
fenwickfanMod2mo ago
ngl @HockeytownHank's just mad cuz we had a good development year, imo Calder Cup win was biggest positive of our offseason so far

@GriffinsGabe I'm happy about the Calder Cup win too, but let's not confuse a successful minor league season with actual progress on the NHL roster - Sebastian Cossa is the only player from that team likely to make an impact next year and we traded him.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Create a free account to reply, light the lamp, earn rep, and claim the Founding Member badge before the window closes.